Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Fighting the Pipeline
By Reginald Johnson
NEW HAVEN --- Chanting and banging on cans, about 25 protesters braved blustery March winds as they demonstrated in front of TD Bank on Chapel Street, trying to alert customers to the bank’s role in funding the controversial Keystone XL pipeline project.
The Keystone will ship hundreds of thousands of barrels of heavy tar sand from Alberta to refineries in Texas, if the pipeline gets built. Critics say the project will lead to massive new releases of carbon into the atmosphere and worsen climate change.
“Hey, hey, ho, ho, the pipeline’s gotta go. Hey, hey, ho, ho, the pipeline’s gotta go,” the group chanted.
Another ditty went “Hey TD! Leave tar sands alone! We don’t need the dirty oil. Leave the tar sands in the soil!”
Rebecca Burton, of Occupy Hartford, was one of those at the protest last Saturday, part of a number of actions around the country aimed at stopping the Keystone project. Burton said that all phases of the pipeline project, the extraction of the tar sands, the transport, the refinemnent , and the use of it, will trigger harmful emissions.
Some experts believe those releases in turn could lead to runaway climate change, with catastrophic consequences for the human race. Leading NASA scientist Dr. James Hansen, for instance, said last year that if the Keystone project is approved it will be “game over for the climate.”
Appropriately, Burton carried a sign that read “Tar Sands = Game Over.”
Burton also maintained that contrary to the claims by backers of the project, the oil produced won’t significantly help U.S. energy supplies.
“A lot of people don’t know this, but most of the oil will be shipped overseas to China and India,” she said.
The Keystone XL project, now the subject of an environmental review by the State Department, will ultimately be approved or not approved by President Barack Obama. The decision is expected within the next few months.
Some of the protesters handed passersby leaflets that read “Ditch TD. Stand with Us.” The leaflet, produced by an environmental organization called “350 Connecticut,” said that TD bank holds over 23 million shares in TransCanada, the Canadian energy company behind Keystone XL. Between 2007 and 2010, the flyer said, TD invested $993 million in corporate loans to fund the project and the bank stands to make “huge profits.”
Ben Martin, an activist from Wallingford, said the group hopes to persuade people not to put their deposits in TD bank, because in the long run that investment harms them.
“With the money people put in their bank, they are basically investing that money into tar sands, which will kill the people that put money in the bank,” he said.
Martin has been involved in the battle against Keystone from the early stages in 2010, when protesters first did civil disobedience actions close to the White House. Since then the protests have grown, with tens of thousands of people taking part, both in Washington and around the country.
The protesters also had a message for President Obama, with this song: “Hey Obama, we don’t want no pipeline drama! Hey Obama we don’t want no pipeline drama!”
.
Sunday, March 17, 2013
Downgrading Ed Schultz
By Reginald Johnson
Ed Schultz is telling everyone that it was his idea to be reassigned from his prime-time 8 p.m. show during the week on MSNBC to a two-hour time slot late Saturday and Sunday. After telling listeners about the change on Wednesday, Schultz said he’s happy about it because now he’ll have the time to do more in-depth stories on issues, which he couldn’t do before.
Maybe he really means it. But I’m not sure.
I’m skeptical because of the timing of the change, which will see Chris Hayes take over the 8 p.m weeknight slot as of today and be pitted against Bill O’Reilly of FOX and Anderson Cooper of CNN. Schultz had been getting increasingly agitated over the possibility of President Obama and the Democrats caving in to the GOP to allow cuts in social safety net programs like Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, as part of a “grand bargain” for reducing the deficit.
One week before the change was announced, Schultz said he had always supported Obama, but now was wavering. One night before he announced his change, Schultz said "President Obama really could be the president to start the undooing of the New Deal."
Ouch. That line had to go over very badly with the White House and senior Democrats. It’s quite possible that the White House called to complain, and put pressure on the pro-Democratic network to push Schultz aside.
Such pressure, if it took place, together with likely dismay on the part of network management already over Schultz’ relentless and passionate defense of unions and “The Big Three” --- which so many in the business community want to cut back --- may have been the reason for removing Schultz in the middle of the week. No transition period, just boom, you’re now at a different time slot.
Obviously, this scenario is just speculation --- I have no proof to back it up. But it sure looks like a demotion of another outspoken liberal by MSNBC. Recall this is the same network that in the past found reasons for removing progressives Keith Olbermann and Cenk Uygur.
Some media analysts maintained the switch came about simply because MSNBC wanted to make a “tone change” at 8 p.m. With his populist approach, Schultz may have been seen as out of step with other network commentators who are more wonkish and intellectual, such as Hayes, Rachel Maddow and Lawrence O’Donnell. The suggestion is that the network thinks they can do better with this kind of style, particularly in terms of reaching a younger demographic.
I don’t want to indirectly bad mouth Chris Hayes. From what I’ve seen of him when he’s filled in at night or on his “Up with Chris Hayes” show early Saturday and Sunday, he’s not too bad. Bright, thoughtful, and seems to be progressive, (although one media analysis labeled him “right of center.”) Even if he turns out consistently progressive, however, I doubt he will show the kind of fire Schultz did in defending the safety net and the interests of labor.
Remember Schultz' on-the-scene reporting in Wisconsin two years ago with union protesters fighting Gov. Scott Walker? Those shows were memorable and unique in TV journalism.
The apparent sidelining of Ed Schultz couldn’t come at a worse time. Progressives are fighting a bitter struggle against Republicans, big business interests and now Obama, to hold the social compact together. To win the battle, they need as many strong voices in the media as they can get.
Friday, March 8, 2013
Rand Paul: Making a Point
By Reginald Johnson
I don’t care what pundits like Larry O’Donnell and “mature” members of Congress may say, Rand Paul deserves a lot of credit for standing up for the Constitution the other day.
The libertarian senator from Kentucky may be way off base on a number of other issues, but performed a tremendous service by filibustering the John Brennan nomination as CIA director, and questioning the Obama drone program.
Brennan was eventually confirmed, hours after Paul’s marathon, in a vote largely along party lines.
But people were still buzzing later about Paul’s 13-hour traditional “talking filibuster,” which spotlighted the administration’s constitutional excesses with respect to the use of drones and the war on terrorism.
Paul rightly criticized the administration for giving signals that it might use killer drones to take out an American on U.S. soil, if suspected of terrorism. Such an act would be a blatant violation of the Constitution’s due process and habeas corpus guarantees.
In a letter sent to Paul recently, U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder said the government did not rule out the use of lethal force against citizens in the U.S.
Holder declared that under undefined “extraordinary circumstances” the president could “authorize the military to use lethal force within the territory of the United States.”
Paul said the vote on confirming Brennan --- who was the architect of the drone program which has resulted in thousands of civilian deaths --- should be held up until the administration issued a clear statement, in writing, saying it would not kill Americans on U.S. soil.
Already, drones were used to kill three Americans abroad. One of them was suspected of terrorist activities against the U.S. None of them were involved in combat against the United States.
Paul discussed the fact that government agencies have drawn up lists of “terrorist suspects” --- which have included the names of people who have expressed radical views, unpopular views or are dissidents. Such lists have been passed on to local law enforcement agencies recommending surveillance of those individuals, he said.
The senator said it is one thing for the government to target individuals who are taking up arms against the government, and another thing to target people who are simply critics of the government or affiliated with an unpopular group.
Paul demanded to know what standards were being used to draw up the watch lists, and what standards were being used to draw up kill lists, something Obama has directly been involved in.
“This filibuster is not so much about Brennan as it is about constitutional principles,” said Paul.
The lawmaker offered the Democrats a proposal that he would drop his filibuster and allow a vote to go ahead if they agreed to a non-binding “Sense of the Senate Resolution” which said “Use of drones to execute or target an American citizen on American soil who poses no imminent threat clearly violates the constitutional due process rights of citizens.”
U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., speaking for the Democrats, conceded that many of the issues Paul raised were legitimate. Nonetheless, he turned the offer down.
The filibuster ended after midnight Thursday morning when Paul took a bathroom break. Later, there was some debate on the floor, with Sen. John McCain defending the drone program and saying the filibuster was out of place. McCain, who is becoming increasingly annoying, admonished the younger Paul “to calm down.”
That’s right, let’s all “calm down” about illegal drone strikes and assaults on the Constitution.
When the vote took place, it fell rather disgustingly along party lines. Almost all Republicans voted against Brennan, in most cases simply to oppose Obama, though some may share Paul’s liberterian views. Only three people on the left side of the aisle voted to oppose. They were Senators Patrick Leahy of Vermont and Jeff Merkley of Oregon, both Democrats, and Independent Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont. Sanders is one of the few real progressives on the Hill.
Then the wise, so-called liberal pundits like Lawrence O’Donnell of MSNBC weighed in with derision for Paul’s filibuster. O’Donnell called Paul “relentlessly ignorant” and deemed the filibuster a publicity stunt. The same network’s Ed Schultz said Paul was “grandstanding” and grabbing attention for a presidential run.
Though both commentators said the drone issue was an important one, Paul had somehow mishandled the matter. Neither one bothered to actually discuss the questions raised by Paul.
The Republican senator did score a victory Thursday morning, however, when Holder sent him a terse letter saying that the President does not have the authority to use a “weaponized drone” to kill an American on U.S. soil who is not engaged in combat.
Medea Benjamin, co-founder of CODEPINK:Women for Peace and a strong critic both of the drone program and Brennan’s nomination, said Paul should have devoted time in his filibuster to talking about the terrible results of past drone strikes overseas, the massive loss of civilian life, and Brennan’s role in heading up the “nefarious program.”
Nonetheless, in a piece she authored for Common Dreams, she lauded Paul’s stand:
“While progressives have all sorts of reasons to dislike Rand Paul’s Tea Party, small government libertarian views, killer drones is one issue on which progressives should make common cause with Paul and his growing legions of supporters,” she wrote.
She continued, “After all, it’s not about the messenger but the message. And compared to the Democratic Senators who have, with few exceptions, remained either silent or support President Obama’s killer drones, Rand made a heroic stand. In gratitude, progressives should ‘Stand with Rand.’ “ http://www.commondreams.org/view/2013/03/07-7
Labels:
Constitution,
filibuster,
killer drones,
Rand Paul
Saturday, March 2, 2013
The Bipartisan Gift: Budget Cuts
By Reginald Johnson
The budget “sequester” --- complete with $85 billion worth of discretionary spending cuts ---- is now kicking in.
A lot of vital services around the country will take a hit from this round of automatic budget cuts, which started on Friday. They include funding for teachers and teachers’ aides, Head Start, airport traffic controllers, national parks, the IRS, nuclear safety, Medicare reimbursements for hospitals, and the military.
The purported aim of the cuts, agreed upon by both Republicans and Democrats, is to start bringing the federal deficit under control, and in the long-run, bring down the national debt. It’s one downpayment on a 10-year plan which will see something in the neighborhood of $1.2 trillion in government spending cuts. The reductions will help to ease the deficit and chip a way at the debt, but it will come at quite a price. More automatic cuts will kick in as the years go by.
There’s been a lot of talk in recent weeks that these hurtful cuts should be avoided, and the plan for automatic reductions be scuttled. President Obama, in a public relations campaign, has been faulting the Republicans for not being willing to agree to a more humane deal, where instead of many cuts, the deficit would be reduced by raising more revenue, by closing tax loopholes for the rich and corporations. Many leading congressional Democrats and liberals in the media are sounding a similar theme, and blasting the GOP for creating unnecessary suffering for the American people.
But Obama is being duplicitous here. At the same time he has chided Republicans for being cruel in their approach to the budget, the White House released a statement last month on their website entitled “A Balanced Plan to Avert the Sequester and Reduce the Deficit” that proposed, along with modest increases in taxes for the wealthy, $400 billion worth of cuts in Medicare and Medicaid, $200 billion in cuts in mandatory domestic spending, $100 billion in cuts in discretionary domestic spending, including a $35 billion cut in federal retirement programs and a $50 billion cut in unemployment insurance.
Won’t cuts in Medicare, Medicaid hurt people? Of course. And is slashing jobless benefits somehow nice?
It has to be remembered as well, that it is Obama who really has been the primary driver in recent years behind getting a deficit control program underway --- one which focused heavily on cuts in social programs, not cuts in defense or tax hikes for the rich and the corporations. In the first year of his administration, it was his idea, not the Republicans, to set up the Simpson-Bowles deficit control commission. The panel’s members, after studying spending issues for a year, never reached a consensus on what to recommend to Congress.
But the group’s chairmen, Wall Street investor Erskine Bowles and former conservative Republican senator Alan Simpson, put out their own report proposing some $4 trillion worth of deficit reductions. Those would be accomplished in part by cutting Social Security benefits, raising the Social Security eligibility age, cutting social spending and lowering income tax rates.
While Obama never fully embraced that proposal, he never totally rejected it, either. He’s made clear all along he is open to cuts in “entitlements.” The use of that term alone is a slap in the face to all retired Americans, who paid a portion of their earnings throughout their career to earn Social Security and Medicare at the end of their work years. The term “entitlement” implies these benefits are something people really don’t deserve. But Americans paid for these programs, and they absolutely deserve to get their benefits, in full.
In 2011, when Republicans in Congress insisted on draconian cuts to the budget in return for agreeing to the president’s request that the nation’s debt ceiling be raised --- so the nation could borrow enough money to keep government operations going --- Obama caved in, and agreed to the plan for cutting $1.5 trillion over 10 years. This is the plan, with the built-in automatic cuts, which we are starting now.
But many political and legal observers noted at the time of the “debt-ceiling debate” that Obama did not have to submit to the GOP demands --- he could have raised the debt ceiling on his own, by signing an executive order. Former President Bill Clinton was among those who said he had that power.
The sad truth is that Obama wants to see a smaller government, and agrees with the Republicans in good part about cutting government spending, and that includes the safety-net programs like Social Security. He is strongly influenced by the business community, which wants social programs reduced to keep corporate taxes down and head off the possibility that corporations pay for the rising debt.
Some Wall Street investment houses, I believe, also see the cuts as a way to deliberately weaken the Social Security program, thus paving the way for privatization --- creating a bonanza for them.
It is true that Republicans, particularly the tea party faction in the House, have been pushing irresponsibly for deep spending cuts, without any tax hikes and they have been unwilling to negotiate on any reasonable terms about how to reduce the deficit. So they are very much to blame for the fiasco that is now unfolding.
But the idea that Obama has been boxed in by the GOP and been “held hostage” by this intransigent group, is really wrong. It was Obama who let the horse out of the barn on the issue of reducing the deficit, and indicating early on, he was willing to entertain cutting social programs, including the Big Three --- Medicaid, Medicare and Social Security.
Just imagine, a Democrat, suggesting that these landmark programs --- which past generations of liberals and Democrats had worked so hard to build --- should be cut!
If Obama had never brought up the deficit and been firm from the get-go in terms of defending the social safety net, and insisted that the discussion be about creating jobs, not budget cuts, I don’t think the nation would be going through this fiscal war today.
I know some people would maintain that times have changed, but I can’t help but think that a Lyndon Johnson, Jack Kennedy or certainly a Franklin Roosevelt could have torn these tea party Republicans to shreds. Their positions are so backwards, so moronic and so at odds with the popular will that they are easily open to attack. But that attack has to be strong, relentless, and based along class lines. The theme has to be: which side are you on? The side of the big corporations, banks and the rich, or working people?
Have you heard this kind of broad-based class attack by Obama or leading Democrats? Except for a few references here and there by Obama during the presidential campaign against Romney, no.
Have you heard Obama saying it’s high time for a stock transaction tax as a way to raise revenue, in light of soaring Wall Street profits? No. (This despite the fact that many Democrats in Congress are lobbying for a “Robin Hood Tax.”) Has he suggested raising corporate tax rates? No, in fact just the opposite.
A successful attack against those who want to slash the deficit by cutting “entitlements” would point out that the deficit has been caused in good part by a drop in income tax receipts due to a collapsed economy. Who caused the collapse? The banks with their reckless and sometimes criminal investment and lending practices. Now these same institutions, which got huge taxpayer bailouts and are now profitable again, want their taxes protected from increases, while you, the American people, pick up the budget tab and suffer reduced services.
Several economists such as Paul Krugman have pointed out recently that the deficit is really not that serious enough of a problem, that it warrants sharp spending cuts.
To the extent that the deficit has to be reduced and the long-term debt slowed down, the best and fairest approach is a combination of increased taxes on the rich and corporations, a Wall Street transaction tax and sharp cuts to a bloated military. (Why in heavens do we still have troops in Europe 70 years after the end of World War II and troops in Korea 60 years after the end of the Korean War?)
Finally, a major federal jobs program would do wonders for the economy, and get revenue flowing back to the government in a big way. Yes, that would take some serious spending in the beginning to do that, but the outlay would be more than offset in the long run by revenue coming back.
Given the corporate mindset of Obama and leading Democrats, who rely heavily on campaign contributions from the business sector, I am skeptical as to whether a more progressive approach will ever be taken by this president on budget matters. But the people have to demand it.
Cuts in Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, as well as other important domestic programs, are unacceptable.
Monday, February 18, 2013
Fighting for Gun Control
By Reginald Johnson
February 18, 2013
HARTFORD --- They arrived in buses and cars from all over the state, from Fairfield, Weston and New Canaan in Fairfield County, and from Kent and New Milford in Litchfield County. They also came in from the state’s cities, like Bridgeport, New Haven and Hartford.
They were there by the thousands, literally --- 5,500 according to a police estimate --- to take part in the “March for Change” rally at the State Capitol last week, aimed at pressuring the state legislature into passing tough gun control laws which will protect Connecticut’s citizens and particularly its children.
Standing in the snow and holding a variety of signs like “ENOUGH gun violence” and “GUNS don’t DIE, CHILDREN DO,” the people heard politicians, gun control advocates and victims of gun violence, say the time for tougher laws on firearms is now.
They chanted, they cheered, and booed when the name of a pro-gun leader was mentioned.
The rally was put on by a grassroots group, also named March for Change, which sprang up in the wake of the horrific Newtown school shootings on December 14th of last year, in which 26 people were gunned down by a deranged young man, wielding a semi-automatic assault rifle. Twenty school children and 6 adult educators at Sandy Hook Elementary School lost their lives in the rampage.
“We are marching for strength. We are marching to change the conversation and to change the culture. We are marching for safer, rational, commonsense gun laws,” said Nancy Lefkowitz, co-founder of “March for Change” and a resident of Fairfield.
Lefkowitz said the group wants a ban on high capacity ammunition magazines and military-style assault weapons; universal background checks prior to gun purchases and annual registration of handguns.
“We have reached a tipping point Connecticut, our hearts are broken, and we demand these changes today!” she shouted, as the crowd roared.
Gov. Dannel Malloy told the group he fully supported tougher laws and said in particular it was high time to require background checks when people buy guns.
“If you can’t get on a plane without having a background check, then you shouldn’t be able to buy a gun without a background check,” he said, amid cheers.
Three legislative committees are now studying the issue of gun violence, school security and mental health and due to present recommendations for strengthening existing state laws in the near future. The U.S. Congress is also weighing new, tougher federal rules on semi-automatic rifles, magazine clips, and background checks.
State Attorney General George Jepsen also spoke in favor of tougher laws, but warned the crowd that passage of more restrictions may not be easy, even in the wake of Newtown.
He noted that in 1993, when the state legislature banned some forms of assault weapons in Connecticut, the bill only passed the Senate by one vote. “The other side is very well-organized. They work hard. They are not interested in an honest dialogue and they will fight tooth-and-nail,” Jepsen said.
Jepsen also noted that reversing the tide of gun violence will require more than tougher laws.
“We need to change social attitudes. We need to change a culture that tolerates gun violence,” he said.
Speeches by family members who’ve lost loved ones to gun violence were emotional, with some speakers having trouble completing their comments.
“You never get over it,” said a tearful Henrietta Beckman of Hartford, pounding her chest. Beckman lost her son to a shooting in 2002.
With her husband putting his hand on her shoulder as she struggled to continue, Beckman said “Something’s gotta change. There’s no reason in the world why anyone should be walking around with an assault weapon.”
Robert Thompson of Bridgeport lost his son, Justin, when he and two friends were shot by a masked gunman as they were walking home. The two friends survived.
“He was just 14. His opportunity for greatness was taken away from him,” said Thompson.
Thompson also reminded the largely white audience, many from suburban towns, that the violence people are confronting after Newtown, is something city residents have been facing for years. Shootings have been commonplace in Bridgeport, Hartford and New Haven over the past two decades, and hundreds have died in the mayhem.
“My prayers go out to the families of Newtown, but in these urban cities, we’re confronting this problem every single day,” Thompson said. “Something has to be done.”
Colin Goddard, a victim of the shooting rampage at Virginia Tech university in 2007 that took 32 lives, and is now a gun control activist, had a reply to the pro-gun advocates who insist that restrictions on assault rifles would violate the Second Amendment’s guarantee of the right to bear arms.
“People have the right to bear arms, not weapons of mass destruction,” he said.
Veronique Pozner, mother of Noah Pozner, 6, one of the first graders killed at Sandy Hook, spoke at the end of the rally, eloquently recalling the wonderful little boy that Noah was, and demanding that action be taken.
“How can anyone think that my son or any of those whose lives were stolen that day were so disposable that it is acceptable to do nothing?” she asked.
She went on: “Thomas Jefferson said ‘the price of freedom is eternal vigilance.’ He was so right about that. Look what happens when no one is watching.”
“Where is the vigilance with respect to these instruments of death? Where was the vigilance in 2011 when this legislature refused to limit the size of magazines?” Pozner demanded to know.
“The vigilance now lies here with us. It is here today. And the vigilance has to remain,” she said.
Pozner concluded by asking for “change now.”
The crowd then began chanting “Now! Now! Now!”
Labels:
assault rifles,
gun control,
March for Change,
Newtown,
rally
Monday, January 28, 2013
Tyranny of the Minority
By Reginald Johnson
Another key issue, another cave-in by Democrats.
Senate Democats in the U.S. Congress voted overwhelmingly last week to approve a bi-partisan deal on “filibuster reform” which will allow Republicans to continue to misuse the filibuster rule and block progressive legislation from getting passed. This means it’s going to be exceedingly hard to get good legislation through Congress in the next few years to fight global warming, preserve the social safety net or tighten gun laws.
You can thank Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev. for orchestrating this sell-out. Although Reid had talked frequently in recent years about the need to reform or even end the filibuster practice, in the final analysis he agreed to a package of weak, almost meaningless changes to the filibuster, in a deal worked out with Senate Minority Leader, Mitch McConnell, R-Ky.
The GOP in recent years has been using the filibuster rule to block consideration of hundreds of bills advanced by Democrats. The practice of the filibuster --- a rule which has been around for over 100 years --- allows one Senator to block all consideration of a bill by simply standing and talking, about anything, for hours on end. In recent years, “silent filibusters” were allowed, meaning all a senator had to do to stall legislation was merely file a statement that he was filbustering a bill. The senator did not have to stand on the Senate floor and justify his or her reasons for blocking a bill.
The only way to end a filibuster is for bill proponents to gather at least 60 votes in the Senate and vote for “cloture.”
Since Democrats have not had 60 votes in the Senate in recent years, they’ve often been unable to reach cloture and seen the GOP stonewall much of their agenda. The old maxim that all you have to do to pass legislation is get a simple majority to vote “yes,” has gone out the window.
What you’ve had here that past few years has been “tyranny of the minority.”
According to the Democrats, Republicans launched more than 385 filibusters since 2007, compared to 49 from 1919 to 1970.
Reid had a golden opportunity to end this sorry state of affairs and make sure that filibusters wouldn’t be used so often to block bills.
In a special period of days at the beginning of every congressional session, the Senate can modify rules with votes by a simple majority. That special period was last week, and it was believed there were enough votes to change the filibuster. Following last fall’s election, Democrats have 55 members in the 100-member Senate. That’s a potential 56 votes for a Democrat bill for real filibuster reform, including a likely yes vote from progressive Independent Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont.
Reform advocates wanted a tough filibuster rule which would shut down silent filibusters, and force bill opponents to take to the floor and openly justify their action, and not hide behind closed doors. The reform group reasoned that if lawmakers considering a filibuster knew they had to publicly defend their action in a “talking filibuster,” they would be less likely to go ahead.
But instead of showing real leadership and marshaling all the Democrats to get behind the reform effort, Reid caved in and decided to sit down and talk compromise with McConnell.
What came out, of course, was mush.
The bill agreed upon calls for some tweaks in the filibuster rule, which proponents say will speed up the legislative process a bit. But there will be no requirement for “talking filibusters” and the minority party will be able to stall the legislative process almost as much as before.
Sanders joined with a handful of tea party Republicans to oppose the bill.
. “This country faces major crises in terms of the economy and unemployment, the deficit, global warming, health care, campaign finance reform, education and a crumbling infrastructure – to name a few. In my view, none of these problems will be effectively addressed so long as one senator can demand 60 votes to pass legislation,” Sanders said.
It’s not clear why Reid backed away from making a more determined effort to get real filibuster reform. There were reports that some Democrats in the Senate caucus wouldn’t back a tough bill. Maybe the reports are true. But it is the majority leader’s job to get his party in line to back bills which have critical importance, and certainly the filibuster overhaul was crucial for the Democratic agenda. It didn’t seem like Reid really tried to get his party in line.
Ed Schultz, commentator on MSNBC’s “The Ed Show,” called out Reid for his weak performance, and speculated that the majority leader didn’t really want the tough filibuster measure to go through, since that will enhance the chances for a gun control bill to pass the Senate. Democrats from rural sates where pro-gun sentiment is high, could face a political backlash. Schultz said Reid “may have been trying to help them.”
I hope this theory isn’t true, but if it is, it’s an absolute disgrace.
Meanwhile, the progressive advocacy group Common Cause is proceeding with its lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the filibuster.
The case is before the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington following a lower court judge’s ruling in December that Common Cause and other plaintiffs, including four members of the House of Representatives, lacked legal standing to sue.
“We’re convinced that in a trial on the merits, we can demonstrate that the filibuster is unconstitutional and was never contemplated by America’s founders,” said Bob Edgar, Common Cause president.
Another key issue, another cave-in by Democrats.
Senate Democats in the U.S. Congress voted overwhelmingly last week to approve a bi-partisan deal on “filibuster reform” which will allow Republicans to continue to misuse the filibuster rule and block progressive legislation from getting passed. This means it’s going to be exceedingly hard to get good legislation through Congress in the next few years to fight global warming, preserve the social safety net or tighten gun laws.
You can thank Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev. for orchestrating this sell-out. Although Reid had talked frequently in recent years about the need to reform or even end the filibuster practice, in the final analysis he agreed to a package of weak, almost meaningless changes to the filibuster, in a deal worked out with Senate Minority Leader, Mitch McConnell, R-Ky.
The GOP in recent years has been using the filibuster rule to block consideration of hundreds of bills advanced by Democrats. The practice of the filibuster --- a rule which has been around for over 100 years --- allows one Senator to block all consideration of a bill by simply standing and talking, about anything, for hours on end. In recent years, “silent filibusters” were allowed, meaning all a senator had to do to stall legislation was merely file a statement that he was filbustering a bill. The senator did not have to stand on the Senate floor and justify his or her reasons for blocking a bill.
The only way to end a filibuster is for bill proponents to gather at least 60 votes in the Senate and vote for “cloture.”
Since Democrats have not had 60 votes in the Senate in recent years, they’ve often been unable to reach cloture and seen the GOP stonewall much of their agenda. The old maxim that all you have to do to pass legislation is get a simple majority to vote “yes,” has gone out the window.
What you’ve had here that past few years has been “tyranny of the minority.”
According to the Democrats, Republicans launched more than 385 filibusters since 2007, compared to 49 from 1919 to 1970.
Reid had a golden opportunity to end this sorry state of affairs and make sure that filibusters wouldn’t be used so often to block bills.
In a special period of days at the beginning of every congressional session, the Senate can modify rules with votes by a simple majority. That special period was last week, and it was believed there were enough votes to change the filibuster. Following last fall’s election, Democrats have 55 members in the 100-member Senate. That’s a potential 56 votes for a Democrat bill for real filibuster reform, including a likely yes vote from progressive Independent Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont.
Reform advocates wanted a tough filibuster rule which would shut down silent filibusters, and force bill opponents to take to the floor and openly justify their action, and not hide behind closed doors. The reform group reasoned that if lawmakers considering a filibuster knew they had to publicly defend their action in a “talking filibuster,” they would be less likely to go ahead.
But instead of showing real leadership and marshaling all the Democrats to get behind the reform effort, Reid caved in and decided to sit down and talk compromise with McConnell.
What came out, of course, was mush.
The bill agreed upon calls for some tweaks in the filibuster rule, which proponents say will speed up the legislative process a bit. But there will be no requirement for “talking filibusters” and the minority party will be able to stall the legislative process almost as much as before.
Sanders joined with a handful of tea party Republicans to oppose the bill.
. “This country faces major crises in terms of the economy and unemployment, the deficit, global warming, health care, campaign finance reform, education and a crumbling infrastructure – to name a few. In my view, none of these problems will be effectively addressed so long as one senator can demand 60 votes to pass legislation,” Sanders said.
It’s not clear why Reid backed away from making a more determined effort to get real filibuster reform. There were reports that some Democrats in the Senate caucus wouldn’t back a tough bill. Maybe the reports are true. But it is the majority leader’s job to get his party in line to back bills which have critical importance, and certainly the filibuster overhaul was crucial for the Democratic agenda. It didn’t seem like Reid really tried to get his party in line.
Ed Schultz, commentator on MSNBC’s “The Ed Show,” called out Reid for his weak performance, and speculated that the majority leader didn’t really want the tough filibuster measure to go through, since that will enhance the chances for a gun control bill to pass the Senate. Democrats from rural sates where pro-gun sentiment is high, could face a political backlash. Schultz said Reid “may have been trying to help them.”
I hope this theory isn’t true, but if it is, it’s an absolute disgrace.
Meanwhile, the progressive advocacy group Common Cause is proceeding with its lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the filibuster.
The case is before the U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington following a lower court judge’s ruling in December that Common Cause and other plaintiffs, including four members of the House of Representatives, lacked legal standing to sue.
“We’re convinced that in a trial on the merits, we can demonstrate that the filibuster is unconstitutional and was never contemplated by America’s founders,” said Bob Edgar, Common Cause president.
Labels:
filibuster tyranny,
Harry Reid,
progressive agenda
Tuesday, December 11, 2012
On Thanksgiving and the Dispossessed
By Reginald Johnson
Dec. 11, 2012
Like most Americans, I’ve always loved Thanksgiving. It’s a day to share good times with family and friends, have a terrific meal and yes, be thankful for what we have.
I must say that now, however, I have different perspective, after having attended an event on put on by American Indians in Plymouth, Mass. called “The National Day of Mourning” on Thanksgiving Day, Nov. 22. I had heard about this event for years, but never got around to going. It was an eye-opener.
Plymouth, of course, is where English Pilgrims arrived aboard the Mayflower in 1620 and began a settlement that many Americans associate with the start of the United States. The first Thanksgiving, at least according to legend, took place a year later and saw the Pilgrims partaking in a meal with Indians, “giving thanks” for a bountiful harvest and for having successfully lived their first year in the “New World.”
Most Americans, I think, see this history in a pretty positive way. The Pilgrims, fleeing religious persecution in England, made a settlement that laid the groundwork for what later would become America, a democratic society where people could practice their religion freely and speak and write as they wished. Many Americans are aware that at the same time, the evolution of our country was not all smooth, that Native people were not treated well, there was a lot of killing and the English and other Europeans broke agreements and stole Indian land.
But the mythology surrounding the Mayflower, the Pilgrim settlement, the march westward and “the birth of a nation” is so strong that the Indian side of the story, and just how bad the Indians got treated, tends to get lost. Also, in the view of many present-day Indians, there hasn’t been enough teaching in the schools about the Native American history so people will better know what indigenous people have gone through.
“The National Day of Mourning” is an effort to educate people about the Indian narrative of what actually took place in those early years of the country as well as to “honor Native ancestors and the struggles of Native people to survive today,” in the words of a statement by the United American Indians of New England, which holds the event.
A plaque put up on Cole’s Hill ---- overlooking the bay where a replica of the Mayflower is docked and above the fabled “Plymouth Rock,” where the Pilgrims allegedly first stepped on shore ---- captures the harsh view that many Indians have about the beginnings of this country. It reads in part: “Many Native Americans do not celebrate the arrival of the Pilgrims and other European settlers. To them, Thanksgiving Day is a reminder of the genocide of millions of their people, the theft of their lands, and the relentless assault on their culture.”
Moonanum James, a Wampanoag Indian whose ancestors greeted the Pilgrims when they arrived, talked of the many distortions in history about what occurred in the early days and the Pilgrims themselves.
“When they arrived, they didn’t find an empty land. Every inch of this land was Indian land,” he said in a speech before about 400 people on Cole’s Hill.
James said that by the written account of one of the Pilgrims themselves, in the first year settlers went out and robbed Indian graves, stole crops, kidnapped Natives and sold them into slavery for 220 shillings apiece.
James, co-leader of the UAINE organization, also said that the legend of Thanksgiving beginning with a peaceful dinner in 1621 with the Indians was erroneous. He maintained that the first official Thanksgiving Day took place in 1637, when the head of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, Gov. John Winthrop, proclaimed a “Day of Thanksgiving,” celebrating the safe return of 200 volunteers who had gone to Mystic, Connecticut and slaughtered 700 women, children and men of the Pequot tribe.
Some historical accounts hold that in the area of eastern Massachusetts there was relative peace for a number of decades between the colonists and Indians. But by the 1670s, trouble was brewing, with the Indians fed up with mistreatment by the colonists and constant land encroachments. Metacomet, the son of the Wampanoag leader Massasoit, who had greeted the Pilgrims, decided to unite all the Indian tribes and drive the English back.
For two years, Metacomet, also known as King Philip, led Native warriors in battles over much of southern New England. Thousands were killed in the conflict. Eventually, the English forces proved too strong, and King Philip was captured and killed, and the war all but ended.
The victors weren’t satisfied with killing the Indian leader and subduing Native forces. They mutilated Metacomet’s body, decapitated him and put his head on a pole for public observation in a Plymouth square. The skull remained there for 20 years.
Moonanum called Plymouth Rock “a monument to racism and oppression” which he and Indian activists had covered with sand on two occasions.
In their suffering, Moonanum said, Natives had a lot in common with African-Americans, who were kidnapped and brought here from Africa to be slaves.
He recalled black leader Malcolm X’s quote about Plymouth Rock. “We didn’t land on Plymouth Rock. Plymouth Rock landed on us.”
James and others said conditions for Native people today --- who represent about 1.5 percent of the country’s population --- are very difficult. A large proportion of Indians live on reservations, and the poverty rampant. Alcoholism and suicide rates are high.
This was the 43rd National Day of Mourning, with the first one being in 1970. James said not much has changed for Indians since then. Just as they did at the first event in 1970, Indians are demanding an end to the Bureau of Indian Affairs, a branch of the U.S. Dept. of Interior, which manages the reservations.
James called the BIA “corrupt.” He said Indians should be allowed to manage their reservations on their own.
Others spoke at the rally, including Tiokasin Ghosthorse, a Lakota Sioux who has a radio show called “Indigenous Voices” aired on a number of stations including WBAI in New York and WPKN in Bridgeport, Ct.. Tiokasin spoke of environmental issues and how there had to be more respect for “mother earth.” He said present day American society is “abusing mother earth,” and this will backfire.
Other speakers expressed empathy for the Palestinian people, who in early November had to endure yet another attack by the Israeli military in Gaza. Some 200 people were killed, many of them children.
Speakers said the Palestinians were a “dispossessed people,” much like the Native people here. One UAINE speaker said the Israeli leaders were showing the same callous and racist disregard for human life in Gaza as the U.S. military showed in its wars against the Indians. She said comments by officials to the effect that Gaza should be “flattened” and “bombed back to the Middle Ages” were similar to remarks made by an Indian fighter, Colonel John Chivington.
Chivington led forces which carried out the Sand Creek, Colorado massacre, in which over 200 largely unarmed Indians were killed in 1864.
Two weeks prior to the expedition, Chivington promised a Denver audience that he would kill all Indians he encountered, including children. “Nits make lice,” he said.
A letter of support from imprisoned Indian activist Leonard Peltier was read as well. In a highly-controversial case, Peltier has been locked up in federal prison for over 35 years following a conviction for killing two FBI agents in a gunbattle on the Pine Ridge reservation in South Dakota.
However, considerable information has emerged that casts doubt on the validity of the conviction, and there’s been a decades-long campaign to have Peltier released.
The rally was followed by a march through the quiet streets of Plymouth. (Just days before, leaders of the town, which bills itself as “America’s Hometown,” had a Thanksgiving celebration, featuring a “Pilgrim’s Parade”). The marchers chanted as they walked past picturesque colonial-era homes, churches, the Mayflower and Plymouth Rock. There were a few curious onlookers, although most residents were inside having Thanksgiving dinner or watching a football game.
At the front of the march was a banner which read: “We are not vanishing. We are not conquered. We are as strong as ever.”
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

